The First Person to Play for Both Baseball’s NL and AL All-Star Teams was a Woman


The Queen of Baseball On August 14, 1922, a collection of baseball
stars gathered at Fenway Park in Boston. An exhibition all-star game had been set-up to
honor and raise money for the family of Tommy “Little Mac” McCarthy- Boston Red Sox
great in the 1880s and 1890s. The game featured the Boston Red Sox, World Series champs only
three seasons ago, versus a group of professional baseball players, some who actually played
in the majors and others who made their living barnstorming.
About half-way through the game, Lizzie Murphy, the proclaimed “Queen of Baseball,” subbed
in to play first base. Met with jeers – and even louder cheers – her entrance into the
game made history; Lizzie Murphy had become the first female to play in a baseball game
against major league players. But that wasn’t and wouldn’t be the only time Lizzie “Spike”
Murphy would make baseball history. She made something of a habit of it, in fact.
While baseball was her true love, Lizzie was born an athlete. She participated in everything
from ice hockey to soccer to swimming to long-distance running in her hometown of Warren, Rhode Island
during the early 1900s. She told a reporter once, in 1941, that she “always loved boys’
sports. They’re so active, they wake you up.” She was such a good ice skater that
her brother Henry claimed that no boy or girl could even come close to keeping up with her
on the ice. But baseball was what she wanted to play.
Lizzie’s father was an avid amateur baseball player himself when he had time off from his
job at the mill. He encouraged Lizzie, thinking her tomboy phase was eventually going to pass
anyway. As for her mother, she didn’t love the idea of her only daughter being so into
sports. Despite this, everyone could see Lizzie was destined for the baseball life. Henry
would play catch with her, wincing as her fastballs smacked his glove.
As was customary back then for children of working-class families, when she turned twelve,
Lizzie left school and took a job, in her case working in the Parker woolen mill as
a ring spinner. That still didn’t stop her from playing baseball. She played after work,
on the weekends- whenever she could. In an interview with Sports Illustrated in the early
1960s, she said, “Even then, when I was too small to play,
I used to beg the boys to let me carry the bats. Finally, I was allowed to join the team
for only one reason: I used to ‘steal’ my father’s gloves and bats and bring them
along, so I was a valuable asset to them when I could furnish some of the equipment.”
She immediately left her mark with the boys and soon was the first player chosen in nearly
every game. In fact, she was so good that by the age of 15, she was playing with men
on local business teams like the Warren Shoe Company.
At 17, she became a professional and signed on to play for a Warren semi-pro club. Though
her skills were immense, it wasn’t lost upon the team’s owner that Lizzie was an
attraction and could bring in a crowd. In those days, fans in these leagues didn’t
typically pay admission to the games, but rather a hat was passed around after the nine
innings and coins were thrown in. The owners would divvy up payment when this concluded.
After her first game on the semi-pro club, Lizzie received no payment. The next week,
the team had a game scheduled in Newport, Rhode Island. A wealthy port town with a fine
amount of sailors looking forward to seeing Lizzie’s strawberry hair under her cap;
the owner thought he was going to make a healthy profit that day in Newport.
As the story goes, Lizzie showed up all week long to practice and workouts, never once
mentioning her “forgotten” payment. On Saturday morning, mere hours before the game,
as everyone got ready, Lizzie approached the owner and told him “No money, no Newport.”
Without much choice or leverage at this stage with so many coming to see Lizzie play, the
owner agreed to pay her a five dollar flat rate (about $121 today) every game from then
on, plus a share of the collection. Because of this, Lizzie Murphy made history, becoming
the first known female holdout in professional sports.
A few years later, she was signed by the Providence Independents and, then, by Ed Carr’s All-Stars
of Boston. Said Carr at the time of the signing to a group of reporters,
“No ball is too hard for her to scoop out of the dirt and when it comes to batting,
she packs a mean wagon tongue.” The team traveled across southern New England
and, then, into Canada, pulling in crowds wherever they went. It was estimated that
they played well over a hundred games during the season, which lasted from April to August.
Boasted Carr to reporters, “She swells attendance and she’s worth
every cent I pay her. But more important, she produces the goods. She’s a real player
and a good fellow.” Besides being a good baseball player, Lizzie
also had a good head for making money and marketing herself. To supplement income, she
would go into the crowd herself after games, selling picture postcards of herself in uniform
for a dime. She liked to say whatever town bought the most postcards was her favorite
town. She also wore the same uniform as all the
men – save for one pretty notable exception. The front of her shirt didn’t have the team’s
name, but rather “Lizzie Murphy” stitched across it, as evident in a picture of her
at the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown. She wanted to make sure everyone knew that
the woman the fans had paid to see was, in fact, playing first base, and what her name
was. Despite Murphy getting most of the attention,
she never had any issues getting along with her teammates. She once told the Providence
Journal that, she “didn’t have any trouble with the boys. Of course, they cursed and
swore, but I knew all the words.” Well, there was one incident in that 1922
all-star game. After Lizzie entered the game, in that same inning, there was a sharp grounder
to third. Legend has it (and according to Murphy’s recollection), the third basemen
held on to the ball and waited for the runner to get closer to first. He then zipped the
throw hard and wide. Murphy, like she’d done throughout her life, handled what was
thrown at her with ease. She caught the ball for the out. Reportedly, the third baseman
turned to the shortstop and said, “She’ll do.”
As Murphy said later to Sports Illustrated, “What he didn’t know was that I liked
fast ones better than slow.” Lizzie would go on to have two more firsts.
In 1928, she played on a National League all-star team (in a game against the Boston Braves),
becoming the first person of any gender to play for all-star teams in both the American
and National leagues. She also became the first woman to play in
the Negro Leagues, when she played first base for the Cleveland Colored Giants when they
came through Rhode Island. According to the Exploratorium, a museum in San Francisco,
Lizzy actually got a hit off of legendary Negro League pitcher (and Baseball Hall of
Famer) Satchel Paige. Catcher Josh Gibson, one of the greatest power
hitters of all time and also eventual Cooperstown-inductee, was asked if Paige really had given Murphy
all he had. Gibson responded with an angry “Of course, he did!” because Paige would
have never wanted to have the embarrassment of giving up a hit to a woman.
Lizzie Murphy hung up her spikes and jersey for good in 1935 at the age of forty. She
spent the rest of her life in her hometown of Warren, passing away at the age of 70 in
1964. Bonus Facts:
• Because her mother was French-Canadian, Lizzie was fluent in French (well, Quebecian-French).
While playing in Quebec with Ed Carr’s team, she overheard the first base coach telling
the runner to steal second, completely unaware that Lizzie also spoke French. She called
time and worked out a hand signal with her catcher. The catcher threw out five runners
attempting to steal second that day. • Lizzie Murphy may have been the first,
but she wasn’t the only woman to play against major league men. In 1931, a pitched named
Jacki Mitchell was signed by the Class-AA Chattanooga Lookouts and their owner Joe Engel.
A few days later, she pitched against the New York Yankees – and their legends Babe
Ruth and Lou Gehrig. She promptly struck both of these gentlemen out on six pitches combined.
For her efforts, her contract was voided and she was banned from the majors by Commissioner
Kenesaw Mountain Landis, stating that baseball was “too strenuous” for women to play.
• Babe Didrikson, another woman to play against major leaguers, pitched in two exhibition
games for the Philadelphia Athletics, but she was more known for her other athletic
achievements – most notably winning two gold medals and one silver in track and field
in
the 1932 Olympics.

9 thoughts on “The First Person to Play for Both Baseball’s NL and AL All-Star Teams was a Woman

  1. I remember learning about her when I was younger.  Thanks for reminding me and for some information I don't believe I ever knew.

  2. This is embarrassing. I've read a ton of baseball books, and not just Major League subject matter. I'd never heard of her. Babe Didrickson, yes, but not Lizzie Murphy. My amateur baseball team had a woman, and we were teammates for at least 7 years. The three hockey teams I played for, all had a women, and my first team had three. In looking back at all the teams I have played on as an adult, it seems that having a woman on the team lessened personality clashes.

  3. I've never heard of her. I've read a boat load over the years and never never heard of her. The woman who was banned, I've heard that story and knew about Babe.

  4. For more fun facts about baseball check out this video that answers the question Did Fidel Castro Really Almost Pitch in the Major Leagues?:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elqTGzbR-QQ

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *